The Deadwood would get a 5, but there is too much smoke. If you even set foot in the Deadwood for more than a minute, your coat will smell like cigarettes for a week. It is a rather dark bar, with a somewhat western them. There are some rather shady characters that frequent the Deadwood, which tends to scare away the undergrads, making it a decent place to hang out and have a beer if you can handle the smoke which just hangs in the air at all times. I really like hanging out at the Deadwood from time to time, it's just that my lungs tend to disagree with me.
UPDATE: I haven't been in the Deadwood since the statewide smoking ban went into effect a couple years ago, but I would have to assume that it is vastly different now, as the smoke just seemed to dominate the place. I sometimes wonder how they've managed to stay open with the smoking ban in place.