Shake

Approval Rate: 69%

69%Approval ratio

Reviews 44

Sort by:
  • by

    jester002

    Sat Feb 06 2010

    If you ask me, this instant "shake in a box" is no where near as good as a real shake made the old fasioned way. Of course if you told some teenager to make a shake using a shake machine, real icecream, and flavored syrup he would go into convulsions and have a seizure trying to figure out how to do it properly and it would take 20 minutes.

  • by

    djahuti

    Wed Oct 21 2009

    Does not taste like there is a drop of MILK or any other substance from Nature in it.

  • by

    oscargamblesfr_o

    Tue Oct 20 2009

    People from this site should do McDonald's commercials. " MA Duron here, and this delightfully dimwitted fellow is my new crony Grimace! I am here to sing the praises of McDonald's shakes as if I were a veritable Apollo of fast food! These immortal shakes are worthy of praise of The Bard himself, who unfortunately cannot be here with Grimace and I, for the exalted master of English plays and sonnets died in 1616, over three and one half centuries before the advent of The Shamrock Shake...."

  • by

    biggun

    Fri Jun 19 2009

    Man, are they good!! But they're a diabetic nightmare!!

  • by

    astromike

    Mon Mar 23 2009

    Love their chocolate shakes. Cant have em anymore tho. Too high in fat/calories.

  • by

    elephantman

    Sun Mar 22 2009

    Chocolate shakes are the best.....it doesnt matter what its made from....they're good!

  • by

    majche85

    Thu Oct 09 2008

    Just have to remind you guys, that shakes from McDonalds are not really shakesss :) . Find out for yourself how? Ask any of your friends that work at Mcd's how they really prepare shakes ;) .

  • by

    smithbaby1

    Thu Oct 09 2008

    SHAKES FROM MCDONALD'S ARE ABSOLUTELY AMAZINGGG!!!!!!

  • by

    hinata

    Wed Oct 08 2008

    hmm good

  • by

    kristyn718

    Tue Jul 22 2008

    ummm duh....its a milkshake...you can't really screw it up!

  • by

    valkyrievoice

    Sat Jul 12 2008

    I don't do shakes, but I have done some. McDonald's does a mean Shamrock Shake! =O)

  • by

    elaine681

    Sat Jul 05 2008

    good shakes, really like when they have shamrock shakes for st. patty's day

  • by

    jawnjawn

    Fri Jun 27 2008

    not the best trust me

  • by

    sonya433

    Fri Jun 13 2008

    I want a small one please I am on a diet

  • by

    brenden

    Sat Jun 07 2008

    CHOCOLATE!

  • by

    shelby805

    Thu Jun 05 2008

    yum chocolate shakes r delicious

  • by

    loving_my_vacation

    Wed Jun 04 2008

    shakes are about the best thing they have...they have gotten a litte generaic latley

  • by

    myspace_118020428

    Sun Jun 01 2008

    They are pretty good [for the prices], but if I had to choose between Mcky C's or Chick-Fila I'm going to the Chick! =D

  • by

    wades_wife

    Sun Jun 01 2008

    don't drink shakes

  • by

    myspace_130463331

    Sun Jun 01 2008

    eah...they should stick to the flurries

  • by

    myspace_131124933

    Wed May 28 2008

    Actually, their milkshakes are pretty good!!

  • by

    almostamystery

    Thu May 22 2008

    the new strawberry banana is the best but they r all good

  • by

    mantyplayer

    Wed May 21 2008

    sweetness, pure unadulterated sweetness

  • by

    louiethe20th

    Wed May 21 2008

    The shake is fair if nothing else is close by, but nothing to write home about.

  • by

    blueorchid

    Mon May 19 2008

    Their chocolate shakes are always my favorite thing to order!

  • by

    full_of_wonder_and_questions

    Sat May 17 2008

    OMP!!! these r so awesome!!! i love ALL THREE flavors and theyre r so good especially when its a schorchin hot day outside or ita late at nite and u want a lil somethin :)

  • by

    twansalem

    Tue May 06 2008

    The shakes are pretty good, but no better or worse than most fast food shakes.

  • by

    trebon1038

    Mon May 05 2008

    I think McDonalds has decent shakes. The only drawback is lack of selection of flavors, but on a hot day Ive been known to run through the drive through and order a vanilla shake.

  • by

    sperryc

    Mon May 05 2008

    I love McD's shakes. I will make a special trip to McD's just for a shake.

  • by

    sawa07a8

    Sat Oct 27 2007

    my personal favorite shake is chocolae, i dislike bk`s shakes compared to mickey d`s.

  • by

    cactushinge

    Thu Jun 14 2007

    At first I loved the chocolate shakes but the last ones I have tried were horrible. There was too much chocolate added to the shake. A lot of times there is strawberry mixed in with it because if someone had a strawberry shake before mine then their machine will spit out some strawberry shake into the bottom of the cup. They even disclose this under the ingredients. They add that when eggnog is being used egg ingredients may be present.

  • by

    vudija

    Wed Feb 21 2007

    They're not bad, don't get me wrong...but...they make me sick. I'd rate them higher if it weren't for that little fact.

  • by

    gaylord

    Mon May 15 2006

    I like the sperm in them, YUM. good taste! a+!

  • by

    mommyl

    Wed Apr 26 2006

    The Arctic Orange shakes are THE BEST!!! But, like so many food items I love (this includes shamrock shakes also), they are available "for a limited time only". (And when they are available, they are only at a few McDonald's.) I love the vanilla and strawberry flavors too. My son loves chocolate.

  • by

    mariusqeldroma

    Thu Dec 29 2005

    I happen to enjoy small ones. They get cold after a while, so i switch from this to something else after a bit.

  • by

    drummond

    Thu Dec 29 2005

    I've heard they're called "shakes" because they don't have enough milk to legally call them "milkshakes." In any case, they're ghastly.

  • by

    traderboy

    Mon Oct 17 2005

    When you can't stand another fizzy-sweet *belch* echoing around the back of your throat, you can reach for the chill-coated calm that only a fast-food milkshake brings. This is one of the few areas where McDonald's has actually improved upon one of its staples. Six years ago, they were sandy and salty, dissolving into slush within 20 minutes of having them handed to you (regardless of flavor preference). After receiving a slew of complaints (I certainly did MY part), they announced a change marketed as "triple thick", and it lived up to its billing; colder, creamier, and with more-intense flavoring (especially with the chocolate). HATED the gimmicky show pitches (that damned clear-plastic, open-top igloo with the spoon sticking out of it; repeated e-mails to the company failed to clean the stains out of my car's carpeting after one too many spills), but the shake remains solid to this day. Not the best (the Wendy's Frosty is the de facto standard, but you can't use a straw with it) or ... Read more

  • by

    93century

    Thu Jul 14 2005

    The shakes are good, but way too thick. I would have to suck on the straw really hard to sip it up. I usually prefer the strawberry shake, but cherish the shamrock shake for a limited time. The prices for shakes are getting rediculus.

  • by

    irishgit

    Fri Mar 05 2004

    Tastes like potato flakes mixed with motor oil, with a bit of flavouring thrown in.

  • by

    kolby1973

    Wed Feb 25 2004

    Once again, McDonald's is NOT Dairy Queen, give it up people ! Stick with burgers, as that is all you really know...

  • by

    moosekarloff

    Tue Jul 08 2003

    This is nothing more than lard, i.e., animal fat, whipped together with loads of sugar and artificial flavorings. Yummie!!!

  • by

    jimmyinatlanta

    Mon Jun 30 2003

    Never cared for their shakes at all.

  • by

    redoedo

    Sat May 31 2003

    I used to consider McDonald's shakes to be rather bland and probably would've given them a 3, but with their recent "upgrades", they taste much better and actually taste a bit more like real milkshakes. Of course, they pale in comparison to the almighty Shake N' Steak.

  • by

    getback

    Mon May 12 2003

    These are atll good and it's about the only thing on that menu.