Sabatino's Italian Restaurant

Approval Rate: 81%

81%Approval ratio

Reviews 50

Sort by:
  • by

    sunil1cf68c

    Thu Jan 21 2010

    we like food

  • by

    moogoo1a148f

    Thu Dec 31 2009

    C'mon haters; it's Sabs! What did you expect? There is always a table waiting for you, the service is fair and the bookmaker's salad is crazy! Have a couple of drinks and sit back and enjoy the company you came with. It is Sabs! What were you expecting!!??

  • by

    homemademom165_e1e

    Fri Oct 02 2009

    On our first and only visit to Sabitino's we were surprising amazed that such a resturant could still be in business after the food we were served. Lets start with bread you would buy in the supermarket, italian soft and cold. served with butter in foil wrappers. You call this italian..where I come from italian bread is crunchy and served with olive oil and olives or something apptetizing. Next salad iceberg with very few vegtables to say the least.Dinner OH MAMMA chicken and veal somewhat rubberized and clams and linguine made right out of a can. Have you heard of bay leaf in clams. Sides of pasta served with a sauce that tasted like ketchup. If this is italian I have been glad to be at sabatino to really appreciate a good sauce. Don't waste your tastebuds or money on this so called Italian resturant.

  • by

    johnnymo1b9940

    Wed Sep 30 2009

    I was visiting Baltimore for a business meeting and several of my co-workers suggested Sabatino's from previous trips to the city. I was NOT disappointed. I was greeted by a friendly host at the front door, seated immediately and served by a very attentive waiter. I had a Bookmaker Salad which was delicious. My Veal Cacciatore was perfectly tender in a wonderful and obviously freshly prepared marinara sauce with just the right texture. My side order of penne vodka was served al dente - as it should be - and it was really tasty, too. I travel frequently for business and dine out often. If my travels bring me anywhere near Sabatino's in the future, I will definitely be back!

  • by

    nanaandgg12593_a

    Sun Sep 27 2009

    sabs has been around a long time and the food has always been very good the service is also very good I've been in the service industry for a long time and I always go to sabs for a great meal

  • by

    jeslo12131f963_f

    Sun Sep 20 2009

    im a frequent customer of sabs and only because their service and food are so consistently good, i read some of these reviews and just encourage people to not let one bad experience keep you from going back. Sabs is family friendly when ever i have a family event i go their because it feels like they are apart of my family. Servers have been there for years. That should say something about the work environment. I ask one server and she said she was there for like thirty years wow. I dont normally write these reviews but i thought sabs was getting alot of bad slack and wanted to give them the review that they deserves. Go to sabs become apart of the family.

  • by

    jimbo6231be4b9

    Wed Sep 02 2009

    Just stay away! The menu was unimpressive, the specials posted on the outside sandwich board were not really "specials" but normal menu items. The Bookmaker Salad was comprised of iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, a couple of bland olives, cut up salami, tasteless cubes of some nondescript cheese, and pieces of shrimp that had any and all of its flavor somehow removed. The House Dressing, although full bodied, was also devoid of flavor, but had a nice flavorless gritty texture. The Bread was adequate, but if you go to the trouble of serving it wrapped in a napkin in a breadbasket, please heat it a little!

  • by

    tamsmith1c5e3e

    Tue Jul 28 2009

    Had a waitress that looked like a big red neck, had to track her down everytime we needed anything. The two tiny mannicotti was frozen inside, and there was just tons and tons of sauce, literally enough sauce for a family, and it tasted exactly like Chef boy ardee meat ravioli sauce. We had to pay "Extra" for the house dressing? AND, to top it off, the veal parm was so salty we couldn't eat it. I told the waitress we didn't like our meals, and she DID take them off the $50 bill. But, she never asked why or said one word to us, we just saw the meals taken off the bill. The floors were dirty too. What a disappointment.

  • by

    reginaldbuxley_1130cb

    Wed Jul 22 2009

    Look, The bookmaker salad is hands down the best value in Little It. When you go anywhere else you're looking at $15-16 for a salad 1/3rd the size. Salami, Shrimp, Lettuce, Eggs and dressing -- all you need. For all those crazy cooks out there in culinary complaint land they've never had a high quality ingredient based dressing that is of the utmost respect to the littlest of italy. That "grit" you taste is authentic Parmesan coming right from the motherland. I apologize that you're tongue can't handle such delicate intricacies so if you need your food refined and processed down to Gerber quality, go hit-up Olive Garden and have them nuke you some dinner in the micro-oven. Boolean true;

  • by

    citysearchuser_1f8b5f

    Sun Nov 09 2008

    This is possibly the worst Italian food I have ever had. I had the Eggplant Parmesan.. how could an Italian restaurant mess that up.I litera...

  • by

    joeby107805

    Fri Jul 25 2008

    The Bookmaker salad is gross. The dressing is gritty. Plenty of other reviews have stated the same thing. There is sand in this dressing........period. The entree's are typical low class Jersey garbage. This is not Italian food at all. You are better off picking a fronzen dinner at Safeway than this pablum. Had the food be flavorless I would have given it two stars. Since it tasted like sweaty feet I gave it one. Although, I am frustrated with paying $40 to eat freshmen year dining hall food, the most amazing part of the night was walking through the restaurant to get to the bathroom and seeing every single table packed. For the love of God, do not eat here. Go to Cafe Troia in Towson for the real deal.

  • by

    danloc7816fffd

    Mon Jul 21 2008

    Only reason it gets a star is for the friendly service. And even then, our server disappeared for about 20 minutes while we waited to exchange our salad, which was drenched in a house dressing that had an overly sandy texture to it. Friend selected balsamic vinaigrette as a replacement dressing...what we received was neither balsamic, nor vinaigrette. Next we were served eight dollar 'fried mozzarella', which were clearly frozen mozzarella sticks. My friend had the veal scallopini, which looked and tasted more like a hungry man dinner than an italian specialty. I actually did enjoy my entree, which was the tortellini with tortellini sauce. But overall, less than authentic, and just poor food, especially for the price.

  • by

    abigale31d11b1

    Sat Jul 19 2008

    I'm not sure many people know about the inner working of this place. Being a former employee, well, I can tell you some stories. MInd you, I am not disgruntled and therefore am not writing this in anger but I just think the public should know what it's putting into it's mouth!! In my 3 years employed there, I witnessed cooks smoking cigarettes WHILE cooking your food (some of the ashes not exactly making it int the ashtray if you know what I mean...), big sweaty cooks digging into the pots of pasta with their big sweaty hands and a cigarette in their mouths. It was the most dirtiest disgusting place I've ever worked at. The thing that really surprised me though? The night that the new bussboy threw away the bowl of cheese dressing that a customer had requested to dip their bread into. Vince Sabatino himself rushed into the kitchen and basically reamed him out in front of the entire kitchen for dumping it out, saying that it could have been reused!!! So against health code violations!!!... Read more

  • by

    silverspringfo_od3473

    Fri Jun 20 2008

    From the grease ladened calamari to the bland ravioli, this meal was forgettable. The dressing, which they rave over, was gritty and almost made me gag. I would not recommend this place. In fairness, I must say, the wait service was friendly.

  • by

    citysearchuser_14c1eb_20382645

    Sat Jun 07 2008

    I ate at this restaurant 3 years ago on a business trip and loved the veal Parmesan. I couldn't wait to go back again. I live in Vermont and...

  • by

    citysearchuser_1ff39214456041_10

    Wed Apr 02 2008

    After a huge build up, my guest and I were unimpressed. I thought for the rude service, bad seating, poor cooking, and noisy dining room you...

  • by

    westernfb11333_4

    Sat May 05 2007

    I went to Sab's a couple of nights ago. It had been about 23 years since I had eaten there. I remembered how wonderful the Bookmaker salad was and how I had to scrape up just enough money to afford that and a couple of drinks. I always vowed that I would go back when I could afford a full-blown dining experience. Finally, I did so, two days ago on a vist to Little Italy. The Bookmaker salad was disappointing. To be specific, it was the dressing, perhaps the centerpiece of the salad, that was disappointing. The ingredients were so gritty that it felt as though the cheese had been replace with sand. It was nasty. As for the main course, a meat ravioli "Al Gus," there were six small ravioli in a sauce that tasted like a bland chicken stock with a few slices of pepper and olive thrown in. The meat filling was also bland. I was stunned, given my memory and reviews I have read. I've had better Italian dining experiences at chain restaurants. Perhaps it was just a bad day for S... Read more

  • by

    tonibac1b5e26

    Fri Jan 26 2007

    My husband and I were out downtown with another couple and we had an GREAT experience at Sabatino's last night. It was a busy Friday night, but we were seated within minutes, even without a reservation. We were greeted warmly at the door when we arrived by a smiling host who seemed genuinely friendly. We were seated on the 2nd floor in a cozy little room with lace curtained windows. Our server was quick to get us started with drinks and a rundown of specials. She was friendly and knowledgable about the menu and quick to suggest her personal favorites. We started with a Bookmaker Salad - just 1 for the 4 of us to share - which was HUGE and AMAZING and enough for us all to share. We skipped appetizers - just not hungry enough to eat that many courses. We all ordered different entrees so we could pass them around the table. We tried the Veal Francese a la Sabatino, Baked Rigatoni, Chicken Lynn and Shrimp Renato. All 4 entrees were delicious! My personal favorite was the Shrimp... Read more

  • by

    sedeplacer112c_e0

    Mon Aug 28 2006

    Didn't think I could go wrong with a 9 rating but this was possibly the worst meal I've had in a long time. I had the fruti de mare with white sauce. I live in central (land locked) Texas and we have better seafood at chain restaurants. I've been to Italy and, there, the meal is an entire evening's entertainment. We received our appetizer before we had even ordered wine. The salad plate was picked up at the same time the entry was delivered. If you are looking for authentic Italian, this is not the place. If the seafood can't be as good as as a chain restaurant, then take it off the menu. If you can't let diner's dine leisurely, then call it a fast food joint. They couldn't even successfully call us a cab.

  • by

    citysearchuser_12d76a

    Thu Aug 24 2006

    Sabatino's has the best homemade pasta dishes in Baltimore. If you've never had fresh pasta, it's like homemade bread as compared to store ...

  • by

    bmorelove17fdb_7

    Sun Jun 04 2006

    "This might be the best Fettuccine Alfredo I've ever had," said one of the ten people in my party last night. We were seated promptly and every dish came out at the perfect time, quick and great! I signed up for this citysearch account just to write a review for Sabatino's. Before going, I read some of the other reviews about Sabatino's and didn't believe the negativity. They were wrong, plain and simple. I had the Veal Saltimbocca, which was great. My girlfriend and I shared the famous Bookmaker Salad, which was also terrific. The desserts were intense and delicious. In summary, I recommend Sabatino's for anyone, particularly for groups. Good stuff!

  • by

    ambmore149a8d

    Tue Jan 17 2006

    What a disappointment!!! I have gone to Sabs since childhood. I have never been so dissappointed. I read the comments on this site before going & didnt believe the bad press. Upon arriveing Louis sat us, just like the old days. After that NOTHING was like before...our bread was cold, our waiter was clumbsy & not attentive, my wine sauce tasted like dishwater,my dates sauce was like day old paste, our check was put on the table 5 mins after the food was & another waitress(who looked like she was on something)kept bumping into us & our table causing our drinks to spill. The only thing that was good was the bookmaker salad which has shrunk in the last 5 years. WHAT HAPPENED TO SABS???

  • by

    citysearchuser_1d3678

    Mon Sep 19 2005

    Sabatino's is always great!! I can go everyday just to order fresh bread and their world famous bookmaker salad topped with shrimp, pepperon...

  • by

    citysearchuser_16011f

    Sun Aug 21 2005

    never wil go anywhere else for italian food. Puts olive garden to shame, he he. Very friendly, great service and the best thing of all great...

  • by

    129025911ed23

    Sun Jun 20 2004

    Sab's is one of my all time favorite places to eat. I'm comfortable here with my family, with friends, or just with a date. The Bookmaker Salad is something everyone should experience - it's Great!!! Suggestions?!?!? Try the Veal Saltimbocca (sp?!?! - not sure about the spelling on that one!!!), Shrimp Renato, Chicken Lynn, any kind of pasta with Veal Sauce. Don't forget the garlic bread and save room for dessert!!!! Oh, and the people are really nice here, too. Friendly servers and the guy at the front door always remembers me, even when I don't come in for a few months. I like the way I'm treated here.

  • by

    lerato1632ca

    Mon Jun 14 2004

    I was highly disappointed. The wait staff is slow, even though the restaurant was empty. The chairs are dusty. The salad was okay, after being recommended highly by others. I could make it in my own kitchen. As for the main, the veal ravioli was actually disgusting, imagine boiled meat with maybe just a little salt. nasty. It tasted like it was from the freezer and had just been either boiled or microwaved. The lasagna was terrible, the ground meat in it was tasteless, no italian taste whatsoever. The veal ravioli was so bad it was not even "properly microwaved". I would never recommend the tiramisu to anyone. It was awful. I would rather go to any coffee shop for tiramisu, and for $5....it was a rip off. For $55 that I paid for this outing, it was a total rip-off. Terrible terrible terrible!

  • by

    abcgator1e02e4

    Thu May 20 2004

    Baltimore best inexpensive Italian food! Miami's best tastebuds rates it EXCELLENT! Not only are they open late! but the food & ambience makes you feel right at home. If it weren't for Sabatino's, I'd be stuck eating fast food late at night!! (Yucko!) Thanks Sabatino's! For your great quality food, service & your friendly staff.

  • by

    hunterhoff1631_cb

    Sun Mar 28 2004

    Sabatinos is truly a great restaurant that is what has put it on the map and won it some many awards the food is excellent and the service is very good as well I go out ot eat quite often and the service doesn't compare. Sabatinos is always consistent thank you Sabatinos

  • by

    codymich1f91bf

    Fri Feb 20 2004

    Sabatino's The value here is in quantity not quality. the portions are large and the atmosphere is loud and casual. If you just want to eat a lot of mediocre italian food, drink wine and converse loudly with friends, maybe this is the place. If you are looking for a quiet classy setting with fine italian cuisine, or a place for a romantic date this is not the place. Their canoli is atrocious, I suspect it was made with store bought frosting and chocolate chips, an absolute disappointment.

  • by

    contributor171_d40

    Mon Jan 12 2004

    The Scene The mirrors that ring the comfortable dining rooms reflect soft lighting across cloth-covered tables. Although Sabatino's is large, the space is divided into several small rooms for an intimate feeling. Soft music seldom strays from its place in the background. The Food To start, Sabatino's garlic bread is a buttery treat made with fresh garlic, grated cheese, herbs and a hint of red pepper. For the main course, traditional pastas come with red or white sauce. Veal, chicken, beef, pork and seafood dishes are attractively presented, perfectly cooked and served in generous portions. Insider's tip: the fantastic veal Francese a la Sabatino combines lightly breaded veal fried in wine with a refreshing, lemony tang. Ask about the daily specials for the latest ideas from the kitchen.

  • by

    encarpenter1e8_026

    Fri Nov 07 2003

    Sabatino's is the best place to eat in Little Italy. They have the best marinara sauce i've ever tasted. I suggest the gnocchi's with marinara sauce it is like heaven. When you go there see Peachy, she is the best waitress i've ever had.

  • by

    spikeman199f93

    Thu May 22 2003

    I've reviewed this restaurant before. I had dinner here for the first time about a year ago. It is now one of my "favorite places". I had dinner here last night with a large group (about 95) of Hopkins Graduates. It was incredible! The event was meticulously planned. We all ate, ate well, and ate hot, cooked to order food all at the same time! The service was outstanding, the "people" were great, the food was, as always, delicious. This restaurant is HUGE (i think they said they have over 400 seats) but you'd never know it. It's a bunch of small to med. sized rooms. And last night IT WAS HOPPING!!! I don't know how they did it, but this was one of the best dinner parties I've ever attended! Can't wait to have my next Bookmaker!!

  • by

    jbear981fbac8

    Thu Apr 03 2003

    Everyone raves about Sab's...but I can't figure out why? The place is dark and dusty, the tables are cramped in, the service is slow and the waitresses are not friendly. And as for the food...it's run of the mill Italian that rivals Chef Boyardee. Lots of fried food, heavy and oily red sauce, and dried out bread.

  • by

    marialouise1ca_cf5

    Fri Mar 14 2003

    This is for tourists or the after-bar crowd who just wants to go anywhere but home. Too noisy and crowded. One time we were seated in a small room - everyone else in the room was celebrating someone's birthday. Not only was this uncomfortable but there was spaghetti sauce slopped all over the wall above our table and they never attempted to wipe it off. There are too many good restaurants in Little Italy to ever go back here.

  • by

    sbaron1ef369

    Fri Feb 28 2003

    Yes, they were busy. Really, really busy. But I expected that on Valentine's Day. We had an 8:00 reservation & though that hallway looked incredibly crowded, we were seated within 10 minutes. We had a lovely table in one of the upstairs dining rooms. Our server was friendly, helpful, and always right there when we needed her. Our dinners were delicious (Veal Francese and Shrimp Renato) and the portions were huge. Dessert was also outstanding (Tiramisu). Loved the Bookmaker Salad and Garlic Bread. Can't wait to go back!

  • by

    eliz131864e3

    Sun Feb 09 2003

    This restaurant has good hours and a well-known name but the food is definitely not the best--by far. If you are in Baltimore looking for good Italian food, I think you will be very disappointed. This is more of last minute, late night choice. There are definitely a few good things on the menu, but there are so many better options out there.

  • by

    rickandjohn110_b3f

    Fri Feb 07 2003

    Great Food,Sevice, and the price is right. Love the location nice quiet Italian hood.

  • by

    gldngirl12ad8f

    Mon Jan 13 2003

    Sabatino's has some of the best Italian dishes that you'll ever tast...but under no circumstances try the shrimp scampi during lunch hours. My co-workers and I went for lunch over the Christmas holidays and 3 out of the 5 of us order shrimp scampi. It was not the usual shrimp scampi that I get during the dinner hours. If you could have seen the look on our faces when we were served what looked like a bowl spaghetti soup with shrimp. The sauce was the worse I ever had, so loose and tart, and the noodles were too thick.

  • by

    velocityx147e3_8

    Sun Jan 12 2003

    My wife & I eat at "Sabby's" at least once a month and have been doing so for at least 5 years. The people are nice, the portions are huge and the food is excellent. My personal favorties are Shrimp Renato, Veal Florentine and Baked Rigatoni. They have great garlic bread and the salad dressing is delicious!

  • by

    mcat118fbfd

    Thu Jan 02 2003

    Their house salad dressing, garlic bread and the bookmaker salad, are the only items I would eat at this restaurant. The rest doesn't even compare to "good" italian food!

  • by

    dnej1e7a1b

    Tue Dec 03 2002

    Sabitinos's has past its prime. What was an excellent resturaunt, while its still good, has fallen to cliche. It's a great place to eat late at night but if out on the town in little italy......i would recomend somewhere else.

  • by

    savoytruffle17_58c7

    Tue Dec 03 2002

    All that Sabatino's now has, is it's legendary name and decent salad dressing. The resteraunt has obviously lost what it once had and what once made it one of the top resteraunts in Baltimore. I recently went to Sabatino's anticipating a great meal and looking forward to eating the same high quality, gourmet food that I once had when I was young. I was highly disappointed with every part of the meal, from the appetizer to desert. Thankfully, other resteraunts in Baltimore's Little Italy stepped up to take the place of what Sabatino's once had.

  • by

    ephraimh1041fd

    Thu Nov 28 2002

    My wife's Braciole was fabulous and my Shrimp Scampi was wonderfully subtle. Scampi often reeks of garlic and drips with too much butter. This sauce was delicate and not the least bit oily. The cannoli was very good but I've had better desserts.

  • by

    ebrowne199e91

    Thu Nov 21 2002

    I ate at Sabatino's last night and it was quite possibly the worst Italian food I have ever had. The veal tasted like chicken fried steak and the pasta could have come out of the frozen section in the super market. For the price of this meal, I expected to eat something that tasted a little better than shoney's. The mozzarella and tomato appetizer was actually very good, but it stops there. I would definitely not recommend this restaurant to anyone that knows what good italian food tastes like.

  • by

    edahlseid1ec41_7

    Thu Nov 21 2002

    I was really disappointed in the meal served at Sabatino's last night. The atmosphere was wonderful, and everyone is very nice, and even the mozzarella and tomoato appetizer teases you into thinking the main course will be wonderful. What a let down. The vodka sauce was too thick and was just pasted on what had to be a pound of rigatoni. (Not that there is anything wrong with making sure people are full when they leave, but a huge portion like that usually suggests lesser quality food). And the veal was overcooked, leaving the lightly breaded coating to resemble chicken fried steak. We looked forward to better things, and were very disappointed in the so-called authentic italian food served. The only reason I will remember this restaurant is the stomach ache that remains the next day. Overpriced and overcooked.

  • by

    jirijiranek1cc_d4d

    Wed Oct 23 2002

    As soon as you walk in, you just think to your self, why me? The staff is not only dum, but rude aswell. The Italian food you buy at your local market is five times better then the slop they call your entre'. If you want to sabotage a business meeting, take your clients here.

  • by

    revelation1146_034

    Wed Oct 23 2002

    Everyone in my party was very impressed with their food. This is "drop your fork" good Italian food. And everyone was so stuffed that they had to take a doggie bag home. Oh, did I mention that we got the 1/2 sized lunch portions? If you want great Italian food, choose Sabatino's.

  • by

    starashes1977b_2

    Wed Oct 09 2002

    I have been going to this resturant since I was a child. It is by far my favourite resturant and will always be. the food and service is excellent. The prices are well worth it!

  • by

    gwenyth14dbcc

    Wed Sep 25 2002

    Several years ago, dear friends Josie & Reds, who have been going to Sabs for over 40 years, took me along and introduced me to Vince, Phil, Baron, Peaches (or Peachy to some) and the rest of the gang that makes up the Sabs family. I was immediately "adopted" into the fold and have been a loyal fan ever since. I take visiting friends from NYC and they always look forward to the welcome they receive - even at 3am. PS: the food is great, too!

  • by

    dlupo1952b7

    Wed Sep 25 2002

    Very romantic, quaint, and delicious food and atmosphere. A true Italian setting of food and ambience.