Godfather's Pizza

Approval Rate: 68%

68%Approval ratio

Reviews 35

Sort by:
  • by

    bubba33

    Thu Oct 27 2011

    Godfathers is a typical fast food pizza chain. The service at the Gainesville, Fl Godfathers was very friendly but the pizza was bland...even more bland than Papa Johns and Dominos which I thought would never happen. Although NY is known for quite a few horrible things, NY pizza can't be beat and I can't understand why all pizza chains can't make a great NY style pizza. People who rate Godfather's Pizza as excellent obviously have never tasted good pizza. Pizza is like big boobed women, even one with a way worse than average face is still OK!

  • by

    lucy94

    Sat Nov 06 2010

    p.s. that was from the branksome branch!

  • by

    irishgit

    Mon Sep 06 2010

    They made me an offer which I can easily and happily refuse.

  • by

    susierbnsn

    Sun May 30 2010

    I placed an order over the internet at 4:00 pm for 5:00 delivery, at 5:25 I called and they said that they did not have my order even though I had a confirmation number, the manager said it would still be an hour before I could get my order due to their system being down. I asked why I was being put back at the end of the line even though I had a confirmation number and she said it was not their fault the system was down and I would have to go in order. I assured them I would give them some good advertising and so her is my review. Do not order from Godfather's pizza.

  • by

    nclarkee

    Tue Feb 02 2010

    Well, this doesn't have anything to do with the pizza but since the A/P is part of the Godfather's Pizza. I'm going to post a review anywhere possible. I stopped at the A/P Market/Godfathers this morning to get $20 worth of gas. Well, I gave the manager $100 bill walked out the store without getting my change back. Of course I have to take some of the blame as well. I went back in the store after getting my gas plus the manager refuse to give me my $80 in change. He kept saying I only gave him $20 but I know what I had in my hands. The location is: 219 S. Main St. Goodlettsville, TN 615-859-6510

  • by

    texastiburon

    Sun Feb 08 2009

    I haven't had a Godfather's pizza in years. But when I lived in Pasadena, Tx it was the best out there! I remember it had sauce and cheese and then the toppings, and on top of the toppings was another layer of cheese. Lots of topping buried under a layer of cheese. It was great!

  • by

    rainroosty

    Thu Dec 25 2008

    Great stuff!

  • by

    twansalem

    Sat Aug 23 2008

    There are other chains that have better pizza, but overall Godfather's is pretty good. In high school a group of us went to Godfather's before prom, tuxes and all. Needless to say, we got a few stares.

  • by

    jlovesh

    Mon Oct 01 2007

    No matter what I'm in the mood for whenever we drive up to Gainseville(Florida) my husband always insist on eating here! But you know, those garlic knots are definately to die for! Unbuckle your belt and unzip your pants!

  • by

    ladyjesusfan77_7

    Mon Apr 09 2007

    I really like their pizza.

  • by

    misspackrat4je_sus

    Mon Apr 09 2007

    Haven't been there for a few years... it's pretty good.

  • by

    presdawg69

    Sun Oct 01 2006

    Today I had buffet at the Godfathers in Cherokee Iowa ,in the past theres been some issues,but today ,it was the best,courtesy was the best,and the food was excellent..you should try to go there!!

  • by

    mattshizzle

    Sun May 21 2006

    Not too good. Fast food pizza.

  • by

    curtis

    Sun Mar 26 2006

    i really like your cheese burger pizza, it almost passes for a cheese burger ! i say way to go good work!

  • by

    ih8rateitall

    Sat Mar 11 2006

    Hey Pauly, did you wack em? Yeah I did, did ya eat your pepperlizzoni? How's ya mother doin? Fine just fine and forget about it!!

  • by

    kamylienne

    Mon Feb 27 2006

    (Rating based on one experience at Gainesville, FL location) I think the Godfather just put a hit out on me; they just tried to poison me with their food! ATMOSPHERE: 2/5. A bit run down and a bit on the dirty side. However, I didn't SEE any roaches or mouse droppings or anything like that, so I'll give it a "2", at least. The TV in the corner had on some trashy "Hollywood" entertainment gossip show, followed by a show called "Wife Swap". Sadly, the choice of programming seemed only fitting. SERVICE: 2/5. It's not that they were impolite. They were indifferent. Very, very indifferent. Kinda like the girl behind the counter didn't want to be there, either. FOOD QUALITY: 2/5. I am amazed that they found an EZ-Bake oven big enough to make those pizzas in. Or, at least that's what it tasted like. School lunches seemed more refined than what they had to offer. The pasta swam in this liquidy tomato water. However, the oddly out-of-place salad bar was pretty decent; the ve... Read more

  • by

    daysie78

    Thu Jan 19 2006

    This is the best place to ever get pizza! The sauce is wonderful! We don't have one near where we live now, so anytime we are traveling, that is usually where we will go!

  • by

    traderboy

    Mon Jun 27 2005

    Still rates as the most fabulous pizza I've ever eaten at a dine-in chain. The smell was incredible (permeated everything in the room), and the cheese was so thick it was scary (almost DARED you to wade into it with both hands). Each slice was a good pound-and-a-half, loaded with pepperoni, onion, mushrooms, and green peppers. Piping hot and served quickly with a smile. Sadly, they moved out of this area, and a friend recently found one on a road trip and reported that they're NOTHING like they once were. Oh, well.....that memory (and the three pounds around my waist) will last a lifetime.

  • by

    oasis045

    Thu Apr 28 2005

    The best I have ever chewed on.

  • by

    nasaltla

    Wed Feb 23 2005

    Godfather's is the best pizza in the world! Their sauce, cheese, crust and toppings are simply delicious. I am surprised when I read comments saying how others can't stand it. I guess everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

  • by

    ithastabeshast_a

    Sun Dec 19 2004

    By far the best national chain.

  • by

    billiefan2000

    Mon Dec 06 2004

    way better than Pizza Hut is all I gotta say

  • by

    vindicator58

    Sat Jul 31 2004

    Best there is!

  • by

    taxnspend

    Wed Jul 28 2004

    Their pizza is quite bland. The toppings, sauce and cheese have little to no taste. That said, the crust is pretty good. Aside from Chicago pizza, is typical midwest pizza for the most part.

  • by

    mommy1

    Thu Feb 26 2004

    My comment is for the Ohio Godfathers Pizza places. They are the best. Loads of ingrediants. Unlike other pizzas. Rate your own areas not all the chains as one.

  • by

    harpua2000

    Wed Aug 13 2003

    I don't know why there are so many low ratings. Godfather's is one of the only chains to make dough fresh every day and to not use frozen cheese. Go for a franchise store, though, they tend to have better quality.

  • by

    jaws298b

    Mon Jul 21 2003

    Seems greasy compared to other pizza and they don't cook them long enough for my taste.

  • by

    mrzappa

    Mon Feb 17 2003

    Absolutely the worst pizza in the world. How does this chain stay in business???

  • by

    golgo_thirteen

    Thu Nov 21 2002

    Total old school. The commercials were piss poor.

  • by

    otlady27

    Mon Dec 10 2001

    Godfather's is the dominant chain here in Omaha, where it was started. It's got decent pizza, but the cheese tastes like rubber and has no flavor. The crust is also weird and very chewy. The sauce and other toppings are pretty good, though. Still, Godfather's is not my first choice for pizza.

  • by

    the_waffler

    Wed Oct 24 2001

    Another awful Pizza chain...Godfathers' hog-tasting pizza is only surpassed by Papa John's disgusting hogwash...Godfather's is bland, bland, bland! Yuk! Crust is the worst.

  • by

    callmetootie

    Fri Apr 06 2001

    Godfather's Pizza has the worst crust in the world. It is such a phony of a crust. Toaster Breaks Frozen Pizza Bars have better crusts then Godfather's has. I would have Godfather's Pizza a lot because when I was younger, I had a friend named Meghan and her father worked, and he hated his job, he said he was laid off, and stuff like that.

  • by

    gte32573du

    Tue Dec 07 1999

    Godfather's Pizza isthe worst thing I have ever tasted.

  • by

    gte82545du

    Mon Dec 06 1999

    Dont like the cheese

  • by

    wiggum

    Tue Oct 26 1999

    Godfather's is old school.