Very good for a menthol. They're kind of like candy to me... good only every once in a while. Luckily, I have a friend who smokes them daily, so I can just bum one whenever I'm in the mood. Would've rated them higher if I could stand smoking more than a couple in a day.

I am a variety smoker. I do not smoke tons and tons, but usually about a half pack per day. I like Marlboro smooths as kind of a "treat" cigarette, as they get old.
It is simply to compare these to some kind of a really good mint candy (which means that someday, thanks to big brother, these will be gone). A few wont hurt, but if you eat the entire box, you get sick.
These cigarettes are a nice trade-off when marlboro menthol plain gets old for me. I'll smoke one or 2 of these and then go to Marlboro Medium or Marlboro Special Blend (Yes, I know, they started making them again, yay!).

Stinkiness - 5.5/10 (about like all marlboro, but this particular blend does not linger as others do.)
Flavor / Taste - 9.5/10 (they are good for an occasional, but can get old)
Strength 6.5/10 (which is just about the right strength, actually. Reds being an 8.5, special blend being a 9.5)
Harshness/Invasiveness to lungs 4/10 (1 being ultra lights and 10 being a cigar)

Overall 8/10. They would be a perfect 10 if they didn't get old after 3-4.
I personally would not smoke these daily , but if I were to smoke anything daily, it would be Kools Filter Kings.

THE BEST CIGARETTE IN THE WORLD....But there really close to Newport shorts

these are great, but its not the kind of cigarette id have all the time, theyre nice to have on occassion

i never smoked anything but marlboro menthol lights. then i decided to try a pack of these, and now i can barely stand a menthol cigarette anymore. i really did not smoke for 2 days after i smoked a half a pack of these. they made me sick. now i simply smoke marlboro lights. they get disgusting after 2 or 3.

they taste like candy cane! no joke! and are awesome the first three but then the taste gits old and after like 3 days they really are nasty. try a new port or then new malb 54's

the first cig i ever did smoke. not gonna pretty good every once in a while. especially when your piss drunk. all around a good every now and then cig.

i'd consider these more of a "treat" cigarette. i'll smoke one once in a while but after smoking a pack my throat gets irritated from how sweet they are.

By far my favorite menthol. But overall, not that great. It is pretty nice to smoke these but they do get old quickly.

Gross. Tastes like smoking a candycane.

I LOVE these!!!! I don't think they taste too much like a candy cane, but I do think they taste like an Andes chocolate mint! They aren't too strong, they are just right! I started out smoking Virginia Slim Menthols then I tried one of these one day and I've been smoking them ever since. And as an added bonus, I find them oftenly on sale in the 2 pack deals, and saving money and getting an amazing cigarette is Awesome!!! I will smoke these until they quit making them, and when that happens.... I will quit smoking, cause I have had to buy other cigarettes when the store is out of my smooths and nothing compares, not even the kinds I smoked before I tried Marlboro Smooth!

The only thing that could be better than this is MENTHOL MARIJUANA,<~~ hmmmmm, good idea for phillip morris.

I've been smoking these since they came out and will not smoke anything else. I hope they never get rid of these. I've always have been a marlboro girl and it will stay that way until i quite.

junk if u wanna take a candy candy brake one up and roll it up horrible

I've smoked these a couple times in the past 4 or 5 months. They were pretty good considering I'm not all into Menthol... but I do choose these over Newports so Marlboro did do a good job in competing against Newports. They smell great when you first open up the pack. The only thing I don't like about these is that I'll smoke the pack in 3 days or so and then be sick of them.... that's the only problem I have. They are also horrible when stale, like I can't even smoke it when they're stale so I've wasted a bunch of smooths.

My favorite cigs.
I started smoking Camel Lights at like 12, then I went on to reds at 15 at 17, I switched to Newports. I said that I would smoke Newports until I coughed up blood. I switched to Marb Smooths about 5 or 6 moths ago, and I won't stop smoking these until they stop selling them. lol.
They make my high better after smoking [yes i'm a pothead, too]
I'm 18 now, and I'l smoke these until I quit.

I was on Marlboro Smooths from the time I started smoking until they started making my glands swell up. At first, I thought that it was just the cold weather, so I quit for a few days and the swelling went down, and a week later, my glands were swollen again and incredibly painful. I went online and saw that other people were having the same problem. Overall, I enjoyed the taste of them, but they are just REALLY effin bad for your throat. I switched to Camel No. 9 Menthe and I've never had any problems with them, a nice alternative.

I've always been a big Reds guy, but one day at work a friend swapped me one of these for a Red and I loved it! I have never been very big on menthols, and I still smoke mostly Reds, but for an occasional treat you just can't beat these, (unless you have a Black and Mild Cream, then you can). I don't smoke them that often, but I love the smooth refreshing taste. Now that they are in 100's though, I do get them more often.

i started smoking at age 16.
and ive try so many newport, cool, camel, etc.
but it wasnt until i was hanging with some friends
that one of them gave me a marlboro smooth.
than i loved it.
ive had marlboro red and lights beforeand hate them both.
right after i was done smoking the smooth.
i make someone go buy my 5 packs.
(because i was 17 at the time)
im about to be 18 in a few month and now the only cig i smoke is marlboro smooth.
if they stop selling this cig id probably quit smoking.

Doesn't taste like a candy cane at all in my opinion. It just taste like a super strong menthol with a different type mint taste. They are so strong every time I took a drag and inhaled it felt kind of weird in the back of my throat. I don't know how to describe it but it's like putting ice in the back of your throat. These are certainly not for me, but for people who like minty menthol cigs. I will tell you that they are alright for a quick cig though.

ewwww these are grose 27s% are better

I'm all set with the candy cane taste...

the hit is good and smooth. they have a unique taste, and i think are better than marlboro menthol.

i used to love these but then i got sick of em.
i smoke marlboro menthols now

These are great to smoke every once and a while. I usually smoke regular Marlboros, but occasionally I will pick a pack of these up. Their taste is extremely unique and the smokes are interestingly strong. I will buy again from time to time, but I am not normally a menthol smoker, so I will continue to only smoke them occasionally.

Look, we all know that smoking causes cancer and other health problems, but, (since I'm an addict) these cigs are a specific brand I've chose to help me quit. I enjoy the overall taste, but not enough to use every day.

i love the taste. they r just great and i woudn't go back to anything else. clearly the best out there that i've ever had out of any menthol or regulars alike.

I LOVE MARLBORO SMOOTH!!! It's all that I smoke. I have been smoking them sence they came out and I refuse to smoke anything else.

the box looks cool.
and the taste is as well.
these foos are the best stoogies
i smoked wit menthol.
smooth as a muthafukker.
taste great.
i get em for $4 a smoke shop.
they blend so good,
wen i smoke a joint after the sideeffects
i smoke one of these fukkers and it elevates
ma high.
im only 18.
:)

I feel this cigarette to be one of the best menthols to date. The tobacco quality is high for a marlboro and the minty taste is very unique compared to a newport or a standard marlboro menthol. Its almost like toothpaste, or a breath mint, which I find very nice. However the aftertaste about 5 minutes after smoking is near unbearable without a beverage. A 4/5.

Tastes like a badly burnt Andes Mint. They smell nice in the pack and I thought they would be good. Then I smoked one. Never again.

GoinDownSlow... on all of the prick non smokers hating on people that smokes' cocks.

WOW!
What A Taste!

they taste like candy! but no fat is involved. i am in love.

sick sh#@

My favorite Menthol, the taste just sucks you in... If you don't like menthol this is the one to try, it's not too harsh yet it has just enough taste.

i tried these once and will never buy them again. this is seriously one of the worst cigarettes i ever smoked. imagine lighting up a candy cane and smoking it. this is no different.

I found that smooths are good If you smoke a few packs then smoke a pack of reds or non marlboro menthol then go back to smooths and the taste will be great again. Try kool XL's

I like them a lot but I recommend you use a bic lighter, not any cheap $1.00 lighters. It will seriously make it tasted horrible and make you never want to smoke them again, BUT use a bic and you will be ridin "smooooooooooooooth".

I like minty cigarettes, at first I smoked Menthols but then they started to hurt my throat, then I switched to Menthol Smooths, the were pretty good the first week I smoked them, but after a while, It didn't have that minty taste anymore.

No cigarette is amazing in my opinion. I think they all taste like ass and make me want to gargle a carton of listerine every five minutes.

these are soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo amazing.
i cant take smoking anything else besides reds.
it makes me gag to smoke anything else.
i love them!!

I liked them at first but they get old quick...if im left with these i smoke them but they are rough on ur throat sometimes

the slight chocolate taste IS appetizing, but it's now worth a sore throat. if i smoke these too often they cause horrible jaw pain and it makes me feel miserable. yes i like the taste, but i do not recommend them. just smoke newports.

these cigs are fucking amazing. the first time i smoked one i was immediately hooked. the peppermint taste and the fleeting nicotine rush were enough to make these my prime choice. fuckin right man

At one time I loved these, but they easy to get "sick of."  I had a pack a few weeks ago and will never pick em up again.

completely love them. at first i like them then i hated them and only smoked newports then this guy ive been dating was smoking them, got me hooked and i cannot look at another cigg. there amazing =]

amazing smokes
been smoking them for over a year
and no other smoke competes with the smooth taste and menthol

amazing smokes
been smoking them for over a year
and no other smoke competes with the smooth taste and menthol

these might just be the most disgusting ciggarette i have ever tasted. way to minty. tastes almost like candy. i leave these for the 14 year old girls.


plus these leave a quite nasty aftertaste. and make my throat swell. very disgusting.