What kind of stupid premise is this for a TV show?

Mean and Stupid

If I were to even begin commenting on this, RateItAll would be scolding me to "clean up my language."

Since not many reality show producers have a good imagination now days, because they have all ran out of ideas, now they have to resort to tempting people so that they might break up their relationships and go out with another person, and show lots of pre-marital sex. It is boring and crude.

OMG!!! I LOVE THESE SHOW!!!!!

It was nothing but a huge slut fest that tried too hard for ratings...

So is this the kinky side of Fantasy Island we never got to see?

Horrible waste of time. Concept is inane. Another contribution to the plunging morality in this country....and what an example for young people!!!!!

Another example of the entertainment world trying to change American values. They show us how being faithful means nothing anymore and watching the emotional pain of others should bring joyful entertainment to our lives.....GRRRRR! More SLEEZE T.V. folks.

Hmm, what am I in the mood for tonight? People ruining their marriages for money? Yhea, that sounds good. Nothing like watching people lose trust in the person they love on national TV. "Why did you do this to me Eric??" " Sorry Kim, the producers told me I had to put my hand down her bikini or we wern't getting paid!"

Appallingly in bad taste. Someone PLEASE just suspend the First Amendment rights of this show's creators and exile them to Forsaken Island.

Callmetootie...definitely not tempting. If tootie was crap, not even a toilet would want tootie.

I loved it! It was kind of frustrating at times, but I still loved it. I hope they have a bunch more seasons.

LOVED THE SHOW..... I can't believe that FOX didn't bring it back this Fall Season!! What were they thinking?

This show is fake.

Was placed on a crappy island. Watch the australian one, its much better.

I find the concept of the game not so amusing. As far as I am concern, so little valuable information that one could get in watching this show. Maybe the people behind the show can make more it appealing to the majority so that it can be patronize by people more like in Asian countries, which is very strict in terms of such TV themes.

It was a good show, I couldnt believe that people would actaully go on the show though. I guess they arent really in love then, If they were they wouldnt go there, and see if they needed to see other people. But I did like the suspence of the show...

These couples are so brave!

The gratuitous smut lover in me craves this show.

I really like Temptation Island and i hope they put on a Temptation Island 3 because i can't wait to see what hot guys will be on their tempting the females.

Temptation Island is the lowest form of reality TV. All it is about is breaking up couples, which is stupid. The idea of the show is shallow and derogatory to anyone with half a brain.

To bad America can not find suitable entertainment on a daily basis. It sure seems that all there is left in the world is sex. We forgot friends,family, neighbors even the people that sleep in the street. If all it takes to keep America going is sex, then we might as well join the dogs in the street.

Reality show? Try Un reality show! I only had to watch one episode of this show to know that this show is totally unrealistic. If there really is an island like this, with beautiful single women everywhere, please tell me where it is so I can move there.

It's another one of those reality shows. If you want reality, don't watch TV. I personally, want unreality on my television!

Enough is enough! Take it off the air. Pleaseeeee

it was a great as a viewer to watch and I will be watching the sequel however I would never put me or my boyfriend in that kind of position it would be too stressful and no amount of money is worth that.

Was I tempted to watch these whores run around an island. NO!

This is terrible.

real life soap opera...who would have thought tv would be redused to this.

How about this - let's chain a young male dog to a tree, put some cameras on him and place bets on how long it will take him to lose his mind when the bitch next door goes into heat. Reality TV is just so base. The sad part is - it would probably be a hit show.

Have we really lowered ourselves to this?

When is the next one coming?

GREAT!

SUCKS!!!!!

I watched the show and would watch it again...ALL THESE people say how it was IMMORAL and WRONG...But if they watched it..why knock it...So why knock it if you are watching it. If you watched so it must not have been too bad. I do believe FOX should have done some background checks on the couple with a child...I don't know that whole story but that is their life, If they want to ruin it..LET THEM!

I never liked the whole idea

I really likes most of the show, but I was really disappointed with the outcome, I was for sure that Mandy and Billy would break up and Kiya and Melissa would be finished, I think it was all a scam to get ratings.

I loved the show!!! I didn't miss an episode. I loved the couples, too. I think Mandy was very beautiful. The guys were hot, too. I'm so glad everything worked out in the end. I know a lot of people I talked to hated the ending, But I loved it. It was so sweet, everyone was crying and hugging & kissing. I give it 2 thumbs up!!!

I've changed my opinion about mandy and billy after seeing them interviewed after the show ended.I think they did a good job of "acting". Now they seem more grown up and level-headed. they seemed like they did the show for laughs and exposure. I don't believe the tears and anger stuff. I want to hear if mandy can sing better than she can do hair styling/coloring. Bring on the music! Billy's cute, but as an actor, a little too sappy and slapsticky. These two were definitely "the stars!" It was not great TV, but sucked me in anyway!

i really enjoy the show they should never took the show off......

I cant believe that bullsh*t ending! Nobody got dumped! I mean c'mon! if you had an urge to jump up and punch someone in the nose, or u've dreamed up an elaborat death, or even a boring one or u just want one of em to drop dead, please visit my sight and take a short poll--(Who would you kill and how?) www.geocities.com/outboundsurfer/poll.html

Trash TV at its finest! The psychological elements are what pulled the show off cleanly. Yes it was wrong, dirty, and immoral. Did viewers make sure to be home in front of the tube every Wednesday night? Yes. What does that say about Americans? We love scandal. We like to see people squirm. Basically we all related it to our own personal lives. I'm sure there's not one person that couldn't relate to those feelings of temptation that were portrayed via the pretty people... It boils down to humanity.

it was a terrible idea and really cruel-and although it was impossible to like any of them(especially that prat Kaye)i still watched all of it which freaked me out a bit.I think i'm a voyeur

I really had a thing for Mandy,but when I saw her playing TICKLE ME ELMO with the tongues and watermelon;I knew there was going to be trouble in paradise.IT really upset me that Mandy chose to use the whole situation as an excuse to justify unfaithfulness on her very last date.She came on to him and did her thing with him.Then the next night she tells Billy how much she loves him and wants to be with him forever.Where was all this love for Billy when she was in bed with this other guy the night before?Valera should have stayed home.She spent all the time making herself and her dates miserable worrying about Kayla.Shannon really came out smelling like a rose;I love the smell of ROSES. :

The worst kind of tripe. Quit watching and maybe it will go away.

First of all, given the reality based genre of the show I cannot give it more than a three. However, admittedly I watched all except for the final show. I think this show made me feel really superior. The people were extra shallow. C'mon,I mean Mandy, what's up with the hair? In essence, it was kind of like a soap opera but with no favorite characters. Well, I did like Shannon, but I have no idea why she would stay with dumbass Andy who would have left her if he even had a shot with that girl he was obsessed with. I liked making fun of these people who actually were not nearly as attractive as expected. They were all very average. Anyway, if the show airs again I'll be right there ready to sadistically satire their misery in paradise. Also, how many people actually believe that noone slept with anyone?

Billy is the cutest guy i have seen on a tv show and nearly the cutest guy i have seen on the streets.You can jump my bones anyday baby!!!!!

No,No .... Lame very Lame,Sorry, no Cry ,Show from the jump has been people wanting to be put in the these kind of situations and when they didn't work for their benefit they up and wildout. Lame . The RED HEAD IS A SLUT>>>>> RUN and your a complete fool for letting her make that decision.

This is an awesome show....i would personaly never puy my wonderful relationship thru something like this....but whatever!....I do on the other hand think the show is a sh*itty way to find out if your "loved one" is "the one". But its incredibly entertaining!...Mandy and Billy...cute couple...but i honestly think they both have cheated on each other in the past...Shannon and Andy...I think Shannon and Andy do love each other, But i think Shannon can do better...and i think she finally realizes it!...Kaya and that cry baby...she needs to find another form of security other than Kaya...i think he wants more....Yotassi and TI..(whatever)...No comment..lol