United States of America
4
There are two hundred and twenty-three reviews on the US. Yet all but a handful fall into one of two categories: brain-dead jingoism or anti-American screeds. The US is an extraordinarily complex country, and entire libraries have been written about its history, culture and politics. The most accurate explanation of American exceptionalism, IMO, is that of sociologist/historian Perry Anderson:
"A large literature has been spent on the American exception. But the only exceptionality that really matterssince all nations are in their way sui generisis the configuration that has founded its global hegemony. How is this best expressed? It lies in the virtually perfect fit the country offers between optimal geographical and optimal social conditions for capitalist development. That is: a continental scale of territory, resources and market, protected by two oceans, that no other nation-state comes near to possessing; and a settler-immigrant population forming a society with virtually no pre-capitalist past, apart from its local inhabitants, slaves and religious creeds, and bound only by the abstractions of a democratic ideology. Here are to be found all the requirements for spectacular economic growth, military power and cultural penetration. Politically, since capital has always lorded it over labour to an extent unknown in other advanced-industrial societies, the result is a domestic landscape well to the right of them..."
Update: The 223 comments here might be a record for RIA categories. Most are unbalanced and few are worth reading, though Abiachara is a voice of reason in the moronic inferno, and SZinHonshu makes some interesting points in his usual tactless manner. Genghis notes that most of the anti-American comments are Canadian, with a few Latin Americans and Greeks too.
UK commentator GuavaMonkey's post, lost in the elctronic clutter, is the best of the lot, and as he has left RIA I will reproduce it here:
5 stars for: New Orleans, those parts that Bush & his pals in the oil and timber industries havent yet destroyed, some music (jazz/bluegrass/70s funk/hard rock), some TV shows (Seinfeld, Frasier, Cheers, Simpsons, Northern Exposure, Buffy),Alaska, the Grand Canyon, Giant Redwoods, Chicago, Harley Davidsons, some writers (John Steinbeck, Michael Moore, Raymond Chandler), many movies of the 50s and 60s
1 star for: corporate America, fast food culture, Budweiser, sports no one else plays, other music (rap, metal,r n b), MTV, 'surfer dude' talk, TV (all teen sitcoms like 'Saved by the Bell', all police and hospital dramas, all sitcoms set outside NYC, Frasier excepted), most cities (all look identical when approaching from the freeway, NYC, Chicago, San Fran, New Orleans excepted), for inventing supermarkets and shopping malls, gas guzzling motor cars, politicians, general standard of TV, most movies of the 70s to present day, general ignorance and arrogance among most Yanks about rest of the world.