E*TRADE
1
Well I landed here and read all of the horrible reviews about E*trade after searching for the phrase "etrade sucks" on google. Glad I found some support here of my opinion, and am pleased I found a place to add my own horror story into the mix. Warning: E*trade supporters should not read.
After trading on E*trade and losing some money in the stock market (my own fault, not etrade's - I was an inexperienced trader) I decided I wanted something tamer than the stock market for a while to calm my nerves. I decided to try bonds, since E*trade has such an advanced bond trading platform. I knew exactly how much money I had in the account as I pulled my money from stocks and put it into bonds, mind you. Well I left my money alone for a week or so, but after I went to check on it, something funny started happening. Suddenly, $5 would be missing. Then 10. Then 5 again another day, and then perhaps 15 the next. I'm absolutely convinced this was NOT unauthorized access to my account - this was E*trade's dishonesty, taking my money bit by bit until at least $100 was missing, hoping I wouldn't notice. I decided my money wasn't safe in bonds with etrade any more, so I pulled it out, selling the bond since the yield had gone up anyways. The magic disappearing money seemed to come back when I sold the bond, but I'm of the firm opinion it should have never left the account in the first place.
Well, then I made another stupid mistake. I trusted E*trade with my money AGAIN. This time I had made a little bit of money in the stock market and then lost some again, and again I knew EXACTLY how much I had in my account. I don't mess around when it comes to money in my accounts. Anyhow, knowing exactly how much I had, I trusted these clowns again with my money, and put it into another decently yielding 3-month bond.
Boy, was that a mistake. Their crowing moment was when I checked into my account a couple of days later, and $300 was suddenly gone. Poof. Vanished. Well, I immediately called customer service to ask where my money was. Their response was to check my previous day's real-value amount and compare it to determine: ta-da! I never had as much money as I thought to begin with. I was speechless.
How was I supposed to prove this, when their own records were against me, and I had no records to back me up that my $300 suddenly vanished into thin air? Boy, was I angry, and shocked. I felt like I was back in philosophy class, being explained to that the burden of proof was on me to get my money back. After that, when I sold the bond, ANOTHER, yes another! $200 disappeared from my account. Oh, and it wasn't because the yield had gone down either, because it was roughly the same. Of course, I couldn't be more upset. So what did I do? I immediately transfered my money back to my bank, where it sits today.
After I transfered my money back to my bank, guess what happened? The money was MAGICALLY THERE AGAIN! Yep, my $500 or so dollars was back again. The rest of my money transferred without problem, but that $500 transaction back to my bank somehow failed to transfer successfully 3 times. Finally, I broke it up into smaller transactions and it went through.
The point is not that I always got my money back from them eventually - it's that it disappeared from my account in the first place. I, personally, have better and more calming things to do than be playing the "where's my money?" game with them.
They never gave me problem with stocks, but for bonds, definitely stay away and find a better trading platform! When you suddenly notice large sums of money disappear, you can't say you haven't been warned!