Trefoils (Shortbread)

Approval Rate: 79%

79%Approval ratio

Reviews 34

Sort by:
  • by

    jester002

    Tue Jan 05 2010

    For a plain Jane cookie their ok.

  • by

    margarite_mccain

    Fri Aug 14 2009

    I love shortbread. That butter will give you coronary disease early though so watch out.

  • by

    irishgit

    Thu Apr 16 2009

    I'm not a big fan of shortbread, but if they were being sold by this cookie girl, I'd buy them. http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/images/B001HT7HTA/ ref=dp_image_text_0?ie=UTF8&n=1036592&s=app arel

  • by

    dcamab

    Wed Mar 11 2009

    They changed the recipe! they used to be 3-4 starts, now I even hesitate giving them 1 star

  • by

    gloomyeeyore

    Mon May 07 2007

    Trefoils are a good shortbread, they are not my favorite cookie but I still enjoy having them.

  • by

    beachnut

    Sun Mar 04 2007

    Never disappointed in Trefoils! Yummy

  • by

    divaash

    Fri Dec 15 2006

    I BUY BOXES AND BOXES!!! I PUT THEM IN DA FRIDGE!!

  • by

    cinnimini

    Sun Mar 26 2006

    Another great cookie. Buttery taste, crisp cookie texture. Perfect for dunking in coffee with cream.

  • by

    dappledoo

    Thu Feb 16 2006

    Never mess with the traditional shortbread. Always the best!

  • by

    wnypat

    Tue Oct 11 2005

    Good shortbread.

  • by

    oleary2000

    Mon Mar 14 2005

    These are my all time favorites.. !!

  • by

    barbkaye57

    Thu Jan 20 2005

    These are good especially during a coffee break. When I was younger I didn't really like them but I guess I've learned to appreciate them. They're nothing fancy, just an ordinary cookie.

  • by

    mystic_mango

    Wed Dec 08 2004

    Delicous shortbread cookies. They have a way of sort of melting in your mouth.

  • by

    fabulousashley_2

    Tue Jun 22 2004

    THEY ARE GREAT! I have loved those...since i was a little kid. I can never get enough of those cookies. YUMMMMM!

  • by

    voyrider

    Fri Mar 05 2004

    I have always liked these cookies before. This year they left a terrible greasy taste on the top of my mouth. You must have changed the recipe. Bring back the old one!! If they are this bad next year, I will never buy them again.

  • by

    tinabean

    Wed Feb 25 2004

    They are the traditional GS cookies!! My personal favorites--as good as Mom's!

  • by

    molfan

    Sun Feb 15 2004

    good old shortbread cookies one of the few that are still around. these are one of the better deals since you get more cookies in a box. has a nice shortbread taste to it. Love to dunk in Coffee. Nicer cookie for a younger child if you let them have cookies.

  • by

    mariaj65

    Sat Jan 10 2004

    These are great with milk. I can eat a whole sleeve without coming up for air. They make a great Banana Pudding cookie, also!

  • by

    snlgirl

    Mon Aug 04 2003

    These cookies have a nice texture to them, and they are good for dunking in milk. They aren't really flavorless, they have some flavor, and they are lowfat, which is good.

  • by

    morriganlf

    Mon Feb 24 2003

    These are the ones I hunt down to buy everytime .

  • by

    mans_ruin

    Mon Feb 24 2003

    far underrated...a tasty cookie and it's not horrible for you!

  • by

    mikeholly93

    Tue Jan 28 2003

    Great Delicious Shortcake Flavor! Plus, they are low in fat which makes Girl Scout cookies a lot better then the cookies you buy in stores.

  • by

    frank15

    Tue Jun 12 2001

    There are two kinds of "plain" cookies in this world: ones that have an excellent taste to them (like Vanilla Wafers), and those that have no taste to them (like Animal Crackers). These are the kind that have no taste to them. I guess some people may like the plain, tasteless cookies, but I'd rather something a little better, especially considering that Girl Scout cookies are more expensive than cookies at the store.

  • by

    dorkavitch_chamalsky

    Wed Apr 11 2001

    These are not my favorite, they are rather flavorless. However, they come in those cute little Girl Scout shapes and are somewhat low-fat, so you don't feel as guilty if you eat more than one.

  • by

    callmetootie

    Mon Apr 09 2001

    It's a tasteless cookie??? I can't belive I ate a dull, and tasteless cookie. Do they out anything except for bread into this cookie? Is there any sign of honey, chocolate, or sugar?

  • by

    alicat

    Tue Sep 19 2000

    They are okay but they remind me of grandmas house or something like that. They don't really offer much.

  • by

    theb5402et

    Thu Mar 16 2000

    These were better 15 years ago when they had sugar on top!

  • by

    drag4571om

    Fri Mar 10 2000

    These are great dunked in coffee. Otherwise, they are fairly dull.

  • by

    gard4565om

    Fri Mar 10 2000

    These had the worst taste ever. They need to go back to the old baker!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • by

    curv4733om

    Fri Mar 10 2000

    They are ok. Not as good as Samoas.

  • by

    flai4749om

    Fri Mar 10 2000

    The best shortbread cookie available. Perfect for when you don't want chocolate.

  • by

    nbas696du

    Wed Mar 08 2000

    Simple and delicious.

  • by

    jkri642om

    Tue Mar 07 2000

    The "Old School" cookie. Dipped in milk, this cookie delivers.

  • by

    shafty

    Tue Mar 07 2000

    I know these seem like plain old cookies, but they have a certain allure to them that makes me want to keep eating them with a gallon of milk.