Browse

Tagalongs (Peanut Butter Patties)

Approval Rate: 77%

77%Approval ratio

Reviews 48

Sort by:
  • by

    margarite_mccain

    Fri Aug 14 2009

    I love peanut butter and I love chocolate, but the only candy that tastes decent in that combo is reeses pieces

    Review helpful?

  • by

    magellan

    Thu Apr 16 2009

    Not quite as good as Reese's peanut butter cups, but pretty damn close.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    zuchinibut

    Sat Dec 06 2008

    Chocolate and peanut butter is almost always a great combination, and Tagalongs are a very worthy entry into that category.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    teresag

    Sun Mar 02 2008

    My personal favorites!  And, after having stood outside in the freezing cold last night at the Cookie Booth, these were gone first!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    christar

    Mon Feb 11 2008

    Best things created on earth

    Review helpful?

  • by

    fb551331332

    Sun Nov 11 2007

    I hate peanut butter. I don't care for chocolate. I'd rather eat the smear from between my toes.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    mad_hatter

    Mon May 07 2007

    Next time I see a girl scout cookie booth, I'm going to have to get a box of tagalongs. With my new fondness of peanut butter cookies, I got to try these.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    gloomyeeyore

    Mon May 07 2007

    I like tagalongs, great mix of chocolate and peanut butter.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    allsmiles19

    Fri Feb 16 2007

    All other cookies shall submit to the mighty wrath of the Tagalong on the judgement day

    Review helpful?

  • by

    jnbanulski

    Thu Jan 25 2007

    I love these - could eat the whole box in one sitting

    Review helpful?

  • by

    missymills

    Sun Jan 14 2007

    Wish the girls were selling them while i was pregnant!!!!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    divaash

    Fri Dec 15 2006

    THE PEANUT BUTTER SPLENDOUR CREATES A STATE OF PURE BLISS! DIVA ASH

    Review helpful?

  • by

    cinnimini

    Sun Mar 26 2006

    Excellent! Almost as good as Thin Mints. Practically impossible to not eat the whole box in one sitting. Addictive.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    girlytay

    Sat Feb 25 2006

    This is the BEST Girl SCout cookie EVER made!!!!!!!!!!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    kappa713

    Thu Feb 02 2006

    Best Ever. Try freezing and saving till a hot July day, if you can wait that long

    Review helpful?

  • by

    dunbar

    Sat Jan 21 2006

    deeeees r goooooooood

    Review helpful?

  • by

    violet_infinity

    Thu Jan 19 2006

    Best cookies ever !!!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    misslorebtaken

    Thu Jan 19 2006

    THESE ARE THE BEST COOKIES OUT OF THE GIRL SCOUT SELECTION!!!!!! I BUY 10 BOXES EACH AND EVERY TIME

    Review helpful?

  • by

    wnypat

    Tue Oct 11 2005

    Rich

    Review helpful?

  • by

    texasyankee

    Fri Mar 25 2005

    Only complaint: not enough in the package ;)

    Review helpful?

  • by

    oleary2000

    Mon Mar 14 2005

    They are ok... I am not much of a peanut butter and chocolate together person.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    bmsch1969

    Mon Feb 21 2005

    YUMMMMMMMMM.....YUMMMMMMMMMM !!!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    livestrong4eve_r

    Thu Jan 20 2005

    Very good cookie...no complaints

    Review helpful?

  • by

    barbkaye57

    Thu Jan 20 2005

    These are delicious. Again, I like them cold served with a nice cold glass of milk.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    golden_bear

    Thu Jan 20 2005

    The undisputed king (or is it queen?) of Girl Scout cookies.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    bluefire0513

    Thu Apr 08 2004

    They are so good I can sometimes eat two boxes at once!!!!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    misanthropist

    Sun Mar 21 2004

    I thought the thin mints were great, but these are really awesome! You should sell them all year long; you'd really make some good profits.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    hedgehog23

    Fri Mar 05 2004

    theeeirrr grrrreeeaaattt!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    cocopaloma

    Wed Feb 25 2004

    Overwhelmingly sweet

    Review helpful?

  • by

    samoasplease

    Tue Feb 03 2004

    PEANUT BUTTER HAS ALWYS BEEN MY FAVORITE COOKIE, IF I COULD JUST TALK MY FAMILY INTO THEM, BUT THEN AGAIN WE ARE SAMOAS FANS.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    snlgirl

    Mon Aug 04 2003

    These are really good! My brother and I ould always get at LEAST 4 boxes!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    gozorak

    Tue Jul 08 2003

    Absolutely perfect. Its been many a year since I had a box but as a kid I could easily go through an entire box of 18. Nothing like them on the market.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    ipleadthe5th

    Mon Apr 07 2003

    how can i buy these year round

    Review helpful?

  • by

    sweetwillye

    Wed Mar 26 2003

    tagalongs are pushin' samoas status......#1

    Review helpful?

  • by

    wildcrazychick_100

    Fri Mar 07 2003

    They change all these girl scout cookie names all the time.. i never know what the hell they're talking about half the time...the peanut butter cookies are REAL GOOD though!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    mikeholly93

    Tue Jan 28 2003

    You will love the great Peanut Butter and Chocolate taste in these cookies!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    lukskywlkr

    Thu Dec 19 2002

    Excellent taste to these cookies, not too sweet, but just sweet enough. Peanut butter flavor is excellent. I always wish I had bought just one more box from the girl scouts .

    Review helpful?

  • by

    molfan

    Sun Apr 14 2002

    Kind of like a Reeses peanut butter cup cookie style.We like the taste of this cookie with it's peanut butter middle and surrounded by chocolate. They are good from the freezer too. As I mentioned in Samoa's the thing I do not like is we get so few cookies. I am always willing to but Girl scout cookies and compared to other fundraisers $3.00 is not so bad for a box. I guess since there is a limited time to buy these cookies we could get a bit more in the box.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    princessangry

    Fri Dec 07 2001

    I hate these things, they make me sick! I am allergic to PB and these things make my throat really itch. I wasn't allergic to PB earlier and I tried these things b4 I was allergic and they were really bad. now since I am allergic to them now, I think tehy are even worse, I really don't care for GS cookies, they are too expensive. the only GS cookies I can put up with are thin-mints. thaat's it. thanks for looking at my review.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    dorkavitch_chamalsky

    Wed Apr 11 2001

    These cookies are second only to Samoas, in my opinion. They are so rich, and the chocolate-peanut butter combo is perfect. You can buy imitation tagalongs in the store, but they never measure up to the real thing. A special treat once a year!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    callmetootie

    Mon Apr 09 2001

    Tagalongs are no doubt the best girl scout cookie out there. It's like 10 times better then a reecees peanut butter cup, and they taste so real and when you freeze them, and suck on them, they taste like a peanut butter lollipop!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    i_am_batman

    Sun Feb 18 2001

    *swish* Hi, I'm...Batman! Give peanuts a chance.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    samiam

    Tue Feb 13 2001

    My second favorite (after samoas of course). These are great, rich and creamy with that added cookie crunch. They don't last too long in my house though. My little boys are huge Reeses Peanut Butter Cup fans and Tagalongs are one step about butter cups with that soft peanut butter and crunchy undercoating.

    Review helpful?

  • by

    princess27

    Mon Jan 15 2001

    Tagalongs and Thin Mints are my favorites. Yummy

    Review helpful?

  • by

    jkf_at_4732et

    Fri Mar 10 2000

    Truly a celestial experience!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    maxo4825et

    Fri Mar 10 2000

    I don't like peanut butter, so these are definitley not my favorite!!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    gkdr4656et

    Fri Mar 10 2000

    These are my favorite Girl Scout cookies and have been since I was a little girl!

    Review helpful?

  • by

    flai4749om

    Fri Mar 10 2000

    There isn't a better combination than peanut butter and chocolate. They were just meant to co-exist.

    Review helpful?

1